The day my mother left

The day my mother left us, my father decided to get a dog. It seemed like a straightforward swap to me. We went out to buy a border collie and when we came back my mother was gone. I was ten years old.

1987Swapping my mother for a puppy had many advantages. In one stroke I was liberated from all the petty restrictions of supervised domestic order. Bedtimes and hygiene went out of the window, replaced by endless summer days topped with coke and crisps in pub gardens. And without a live-in mother our family activities could no longer be divided along gender lines – no more being left behind to dig a stupid fish pond while the men went off to watch the Test Match! My world shifted shape.

My mother’s departure certainly left a gap. But as a family we expanded to fill it. In adversity, my brother, father and I became a team, we all mothered each other (albeit inexpertly).

I was aware that ours was an odd set up mainly from other people’s reactions. Every time my father brought a woman friend to the house she would go straight for me, cuddling and chatting and fiddling with my hair as if her life depended on proving how deprived I was by the absence of a maternal bosom.

I wasn’t oblivious to the hurt and accusations thrown around between adults who should have kept it to themselves. But children are naturally self-centred so – as a child – the fact that my mother was seeking happiness elsewhere may have been confusing but I could certainly relate to it.

It was as I grew up and tried to work out what sort of woman I wanted to be that my mother’s apparent lack of maternal selflessness began to trouble me. Maternal nurture occupies such a unique symbolic space in our society. Deemed the sole providers of one-way unconditional love, mothers are irreplaceable. Fathers may come and go, but mothers will always carry the can.

So, having had it uncontestably demonstrated to me that at least one woman in the world did not fit this Persil ad version of motherhood, I had two choices. I could either blame myself as being obviously unlovable (which I did for a while) or I could understand that being a mother is not a one-size-fits-all mantle.

What I really learnt from my mother is that women do not have a monopoly on nurturing. But as long as society believes that we do, women will remain trapped by domestic symbols that have real life consequences. The presumed co-incidence of women and unconditional nurturing both excludes and excuses fathers from child care and it encourages our daughters to exchange ambitions for single-handed child-rearing. Until the symbols and values of ‘mothering’ are relocated into ‘parenting’ and into the community at large, mothers will always carry the can.

This is an abridged version of an article originally published in Everywoman magazine in January 1995. I wrote it before I had children.

Enjoyed this? Subscribe to monthly newsletters.

Please share:

4 thoughts on “The day my mother left

  1. John Adams

    Well this is an interesting article, largely because it is written by a woman. I (and other men’s rights campaigners) have been saying these things for some time. Unfortunately I think a lot of women believe that a lot of parenting is intuition. I don’t. I believe it is learned, regardless of whether you are male or female. As it’s learned, it really shouldn’t make much difference as to who “parents” be they male or female. Last year’s State of the World’s Fathers report, a study of academic research from 30 different countries, concluded that men and women are as “genetically hardwired” to fulfill caring roles, simply that men do not have the options. Interesting academic research is also beginning to drip through in relation to same sex couples. There seems to be a consensus that two loving parents and a supportive home trumps everything, regardless of gender. When society accepts this, women will get much greater freedom.

  2. kirsten

    There are a lot of assumptions made in our society about gender that are so pervasive yet they are hard to see. So whilst I don’t think that men and women are the same, I do believe that men are just as capable of caring as women. My husband does a good job of raising our children. He does it differently to me but that is not a problem. Like John said above, much of parenting is learned and we learn through being a parent and parenting. Thanks for sharing the perspective that your childhood experiences gave you on this topic, Anita. Great post.

    1. AnitaCleare Post author

      Thanks Kirsten. I do think that the assumption that women are innately more suited to child-rearing leads to men being pushed out and sometimes simply not getting the same amount of hands-on practice which, as you say, is actually how we learn to parent.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.